Majority vs. Dissenting Opinions on Law

$2.00 Summary DIRECTIONS: On the left side brainstorm a list representing the claims made by the two opposing arguments (majority opinion and dissenting opinion. Using your brainstorm list, write a $2.00 summary that conveys the two opposing arguments (majority opinion and dissenting opinion). Each word is worth ten cents (at least 20 words). Brainstorm: List the claims of both sides of the argument

Majority Opinion (claims) Dissenting Opinion (claims)

Brainstorm: Claims of Both Sides

Majority Opinion (claims):

1. Upholds the law as constitutional.
2. Protects individual rights and freedoms.
3. Promotes social order and stability.
4. Aligns with precedent and legal interpretations.
5. Reflects the will of the majority.
6. Ensures justice and equality under the law.

Dissenting Opinion (claims):

1. Argues the law infringes on personal liberties.
2. Highlights potential for discrimination.
3. Questions the interpretation of precedent.
4. Warns of negative societal impacts.
5. Advocates for minority rights and protections.
6. Emphasizes the need for progressive change.

$2.00 Summary:

The majority opinion claims the law is constitutional, protecting individual rights and promoting social order. It aligns with legal precedent and reflects the majority's will. In contrast, the dissenting opinion argues the law infringes on personal liberties, risks discrimination, and emphasizes the need for progressive change to protect minority rights.